Full length of stylish woman in elegant outfit carrying baggage and surfing smartphone while standing near glass wall of airport

eSIM or Local SIM Card: Which Should You Choose?

Do I need to unlock my phone to use a local SIM card abroad?

Yes, your phone needs to be unlocked from your home network before a foreign SIM will work in it. Most South African providers can unlock a phone on request once your contract terms allow it.

Can I use an eSIM and my regular SIM at the same time?

Yes, most modern smartphones support dual SIM functionality, so you can run your South African SIM and a travel eSIM side by side.

Which is cheaper, an eSIM or a local SIM card?

It depends on the destination. Local SIMs are often cheaper for data-heavy trips to a single country, while eSIMs tend to work out better value across multi-country itineraries.

Will my phone number still work if I use an eSIM for data?

Yes, as long as your physical SIM stays in the other slot, calls and messages to your usual number will still come through, though international rates may apply.

Staying Connected Without the Stress

Landing in a new country and realising you have no signal is one of those small travel panics we’ve all felt at least once. These days you’ve got two solid options for staying connected abroad: an eSIM or a local SIM card. Both work well, but which one suits you depends on how you travel, what device you’re carrying and how much fuss you’re willing to deal with at arrivals.

If you read our earlier post on international roaming versus eSIMs, you’ll know we’re big fans of ditching pricey roaming charges altogether. This time we’re going a step further and putting eSIMs head to head with good old physical SIM cards.

A woman uses her smartphone while commuting on public transportation.
Photo by Mathias Reding on Pexels

What Is an eSIM, Exactly?

An eSIM is a digital SIM built into your phone. Instead of popping in a physical card, you download a data plan straight onto your device, often before you’ve even left home. Most phones from the last few years support eSIM, though it’s worth checking yours does before you rely on one.

What Is a Local SIM Card?

A local SIM is the traditional route: a small physical card you buy once you land, or sometimes in advance, that slots into your phone and connects you to a local network. It’s the tried and tested method most of us grew up travelling with.

eSIM: The Pros

  • Set up before you fly, so you land already connected
  • No queuing at the airport kiosk after a long flight
  • Easy to switch between countries if you’re doing a multi-stop trip
  • Keeps your South African SIM in the other slot, so you don’t lose your home number

eSIM: The Cons

  • Not all phones support it, particularly older models
  • Setup can be fiddly if your hotel wifi is your only backup while you sort it out
  • Prices can vary a lot between providers, so it pays to compare

Local SIM: The Pros

  • Often the cheapest option for data in that specific country
  • Widely available, from airport kiosks to corner shops
  • Simple and familiar if you’d rather not deal with apps and QR codes

Local SIM: The Cons

  • You’ll need an unlocked phone
  • Fiddling with a tiny SIM tray after a long flight is nobody’s idea of fun
  • If you’re hopping between countries, you may need a new SIM at every border
Hand holding smartphone displaying a GPS map application with location data.
Photo by George Sultan on Pexels

Which One Should You Choose?

If You’re Travelling for a Short Trip

An eSIM is hard to beat. You land, you’re online, and you’ve saved yourself a trip to a kiosk when all you want is your hotel bed.

If You’re Visiting Multiple Countries

eSIMs win again here. Regional data plans covering several countries mean you’re not hunting for a new SIM every time you cross a border.

If You Want to Keep Your South African Number Active

This is where eSIM really shines, since it lets your local number keep working in one slot while your travel data runs in the other.

If You’re Heading Somewhere with Patchy Network Infrastructure

In destinations where local networks are more reliable than international eSIM providers, a local SIM bought on the ground can sometimes give you better coverage. It’s worth a quick check before you decide.

A woman uses her smartphone while commuting on public transportation.

The Cost-Saving Value of Using an eSIM When Travelling Abroad

Why should I use an eSIM when travelling abroad?

Using an eSIM saves money abroad by bypassing expensive home carrier roaming fees and giving you direct access to local prepaid data rates. It protects you from unexpected bill shock with fixed upfront pricing, allows you to keep your physical home SIM active for important 2FA banking texts, and saves you from the hassle and high prices of airport SIM vendors.

When travelling abroad, especially as a solo traveller as I very often am, staying connected is mandatory, and what a bonus it was when eSIMs became the norm for international travel back in 2018.

I must confess that I only started using an eSIM in 2022 when embarking on a Mediterranean cruise. What a saving, and what a pleasure to stay connected at a fraction of the price, instead of briefly switching international roaming on and off to check emails and WhatsApp messages, or purchasing a local SIM soon after arriving at my foreign destination.

So it’s no surprise that using an eSIM saves money abroad by bypassing exorbitant home carrier roaming fees, which can run into hundreds of Rands. It provides direct access to localised prepaid data rates, protecting you from “bill shock” while keeping your physical home SIM safely in your phone to receive important texts and calls.

Full length of stylish woman in elegant outfit carrying baggage and surfing smartphone while standing near glass wall of airport
Photo by Gustavo Fring on Pexels

Key Advantages of Using an eSIM Abroad

Several key advantages make eSIMs a highly cost-effective choice for international travel:

Bypass Roaming Fees

Traditional international roaming can cost R200 to R350 per day, or charge astronomical rates for data usage (R200+ per megabyte in some cases). eSIM data plans are often 80 to 90% cheaper, with fixed prepaid packages, like those found on Airalo (my preferred eSIM), usually starting at under R100 for basic allotments.

No Bill Shock

Because you buy a specific amount of data upfront, such as 5GB or 10GB, at a fixed price, you cannot accidentally exceed your limit and get hit with overage charges.

Maintain Your Home Number

Unlike swapping physical SIM cards, an eSIM lets you keep your regular SIM card active in your phone. This means you can still receive 2FA (two-factor authentication) texts for banking, or get emergency calls, while using the eSIM strictly for cheaper mobile data.

Avoid Airport Traps

You can purchase, download and install an eSIM while sitting on your couch at home or in your hotel. This saves you the time, hassle and potential tourist markups of tracking down a local SIM card vendor at the airport.

Close-up of a hand using a smartphone displaying a map for navigation.
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels

Getting Started

I highly recommend using an eSIM, and if you plan to do so, it helps to check that your smartphone is carrier-unlocked and compatible.

Many of the eSIM service providers, such as Airalo, Holafly and Nomad, assist in estimating how much data you will need for your upcoming trip, and assist in checking if your specific device supports eSIM technology.

The Pros of Using an eSIM

  • Strong speeds
  • Easy setup
  • Great support
  • Excellent pricing
  • Data-only simplicity

The Cons of Using an eSIM

  • Might not be worthwhile for ultra-light data users
  • Data options for some countries (such as the UK) start at 20GB plans

I would highly recommend using an eSIM for your next international trip. I’m happy to assist in walking you through the easy process to install your eSIM.

Travel Tips From A Seasoned Traveller

Travel tips are practical suggestions and advice that help travellers make the most of their trips, whether they’re seasoned adventurers or first-time explorers. These tips cover a wide range of topics, including:

  • Planning: Tips for researching destinations, booking accommodations and transportation, and creating a travel itinerary.
  • Packing: Efficient packing strategies, packing lists, and tips for packing light.
  • Budgeting: Money-saving tips, budgeting strategies, and how to manage finances while traveling.
  • Safety: Safety precautions, travel insurance, and how to stay safe in unfamiliar environments.
  • Cultural Awareness: Understanding local customs, etiquette, and how to respect different cultures.
  • Health: Health precautions, vaccinations, and staying healthy while traveling.
  • Transportation: Tips for navigating airports, public transportation, and renting vehicles.
  • Accommodation: Choosing the right type of accommodation, booking tips, and what to look for in a hotel or hostel.
  • Activities: Finding the best activities and attractions, booking tours, and making the most of your time.
  • Communication: Language tips, using translation apps, and staying connected while traveling.

Ultimately, travel tips are designed to enhance the overall travel experience, making it more enjoyable, stress-free, and memorable.

Yours In Travel will be exploring all these topics and more in upcoming blog posts and newsletters.